Debate
A formal discussion on a public issue—such as environmental policy on BBC Radio 4—in which speakers put forward opposing arguments.
English Year 8 — Cambridge International Curriculum
At the end of this Year 8 Listening & Speaking lesson, you will be able to:
A formal discussion on a public issue—such as environmental policy on BBC Radio 4—in which speakers put forward opposing arguments.
When a speaker says one thing and later says something else that contradicts or does not agree with their earlier statement.
The large-scale clearing or cutting down of trees and forests for farming, timber, or urban building projects.
Severe environmental damage—such as flooding, heatwaves, or habitat loss—caused by rapid global warming and human inaction.
Natural, clean energy supplies—like North Sea wind turbines and solar panels—that never run out and do not pollute the atmosphere.
Verb structures (should have, shouldn’t have, ought to have + past participle) used to express criticism or regret about the past.
Welcome, Year 8 learners!
Across the United Kingdom and the United States, young people are asking big questions about the planet. In today’s lesson, three students—Jessica, Khaled, and Rafael—take part in a live school radio debate in Manchester with two British politicians, Sonia and Sir Michael. As we look back at past mistakes and look forward to cleaner solutions, we need sharp listening skills to spot both strong evidence and hidden inconsistencies.
Click any environmental headline from British and American news below to see key debate vocabulary and talking points:
Sometimes people say one thing and then say something else that doesn’t agree with what they said first. Spotting an inconsistency makes you a sharper listener in any debate!
Example:
“I always cycle to the shops. I only take the car if it’s raining.”
If this person always cycles to the shops, that means they never take the car. So how can they take the car when it’s raining? That contradiction is an inconsistency.
Use should have / shouldn’t have + past participle to express criticism and regret. Note that ought to have done means the same as should have done.
Expressing Criticism
• “We should have done something to stop a climate disaster happening.”
• “They ought to have done this years ago.” (= They should have done this years ago.)
Expressing Regret
• “We should have acted earlier to protect local woodlands.”
• “I shouldn’t have thrown those bottles into the rubbish bin.”
Listen to the school radio debate between students Jessica, Khaled, and Rafael and politicians Sonia and Sir Michael. Identify their opinions and spot Sir Michael’s inconsistency.
Presenter (Ms Clarke): “Welcome to Oakwood High School Radio in Manchester. Today we are debating the future of our environment with students Jessica, Khaled, and Rafael, alongside local politicians Sonia and Sir Michael. Jessica, who wants to start?”
Jessica: “I will! I was absolutely horrified when I read the latest report on global deforestation and how fast tropical rainforests and British ancient woodlands are disappearing. Governments should have acted twenty years ago to stop a climate disaster happening!”
Sonia (Politician): “I understand your frustration, Jessica, and it’s something that affects us all. However, one of the main reasons for deforestation is that growing populations need land for agriculture to produce food, as well as timber and space for housing. These things take time to balance.”
Sir Michael (Politician): “Yes, Sonia makes a fair point. Protecting every forest immediately costs billions of pounds, and right now there simply isn’t enough money in the national budget to halt all tree clearing. Besides, we need to expand roads and housing estates for the economy.”
Jessica: “Well, yes, but neither of you has answered why targets keep getting missed! Honestly, I’m disappointed—it feels like politicians are making excuses instead of taking urgent action.”
Khaled: “I agree with Jessica, and I’m really concerned about what has just happened right next to our school! Last month, developers cut down the old oak woodland beside Elm Lane to build a new shopping car park. As a result, local birds and hedgehogs have lost their habitat, and rainwater flooded the school playing fields last Tuesday because there are no tree roots left to absorb the rain!”
Rafael: “And Sir Michael says protecting the environment is too expensive, yet protecting nature is not necessarily a question of money. Simple changes in habits—like stopping single-use plastic waste, insulating homes, recycling, and enforcing strict planning laws—cost very little or actually save money in the long run. Furthermore, renewable energy sources like offshore wind and solar power are now cheaper than fossil fuels and are essential if we want clean electricity for the future!”
Sir Michael (Politician): “You’ve got a good point there about wind farms, Rafael. In fact, my department has just approved a brand-new multi-billion-pound woodland planting and green park fund across the North West, because we have plenty of funding available for environmental projects.”
Presenter (Ms Clarke): “Hold on, Sir Michael—a moment ago you said there wasn’t enough money in the budget to stop deforestation, yet now you say there is plenty of funding for new tree-planting projects!”
| Speaker | Role | Main Concern / Argument |
|---|---|---|
| Jessica | Student | Horrified by rapid deforestation; disappointed by politicians’ slow excuses. |
| Khaled | Student | Oak woodland cut down near school → wildlife lost habitats & playing fields flooded. |
| Rafael | Student | Protecting nature isn’t just about money (habits & laws matter); champions renewable energy sources. |
| Sonia | Politician | Says deforestation happens because people need land for food/agriculture and housing; change takes time. |
| Sir Michael | Politician | Claims there is no money to stop deforestation, yet contradicts himself by boasting of a multi-billion-pound green fund. |
Flip the cards to match each key term (debate, inconsistency, deforestation, climate disaster, renewable energy, past modals) with its definition.
Imagine a radio debate about the environment is taking place in your school. Practise speaking from the perspective of each role—Presenter, Student, and Politician—using the Cambridge debate phrases below!
Role-Play Debate Phrase Bank:
Use should have or shouldn’t have + past participle to complete the second sentence in each pair from Exercise 4.
Listen to this short youth council debate from Bristol, then answer the 5 final check questions on opinions, inconsistencies, and past modals.
“At the Bristol Youth Climate Forum, Year 8 representative Maya argued: ‘The city council should have installed solar panels on every school roof five years ago. Our electricity bills are huge, and fossil fuels are causing a climate disaster.’ Councillor Harrison replied: ‘These things take time, Maya. I never support spending council taxes on renewable energy projects because they are far too risky. However, next Tuesday I am proudly opening our new council-funded tidal and solar energy station at Avonmouth!’ Maya smiled and pointed out: ‘Councillor Harrison, you just said you never support spending council taxes on renewable energy, yet you are opening a council-funded solar station next week!'”
Tick each Year 8 Listening & Speaking competency as you achieve it:
Welcome Back
Sign in to access your account and continue where you left off.