English: Year 6 9 Sections56 Lessons365 Days
5.12 Have a class debate
Have a class debate
English Year 6 • Unit 5: Poles apart (Cambridge Curriculum)
Lesson Competencies
At the end of the lesson you will be able to:
Analyse contrasting newspaper headlines about climate change and explain how balanced reporting differs from a biased view.
Formulate clear points for and against a motion using persuasive openers (I think, I agree, I’m convinced, I believe, In my opinion, I’m against).
Structure a formal debate speech into three stages (Introduction, Three Convincing Points, Conclusion) linked with sequencing connectives (firstly, in addition, moreover, therefore, finally).
Follow the seven official steps of a classroom debate, including presenting speeches, fielding audience questions, and conducting a fair audience vote.
Key Terms: Debate & Persuasion Vocabulary
1. Debate
A formal discussion where each person or team presents their side of an argument, aiming to convince the audience and disprove the other team’s points.
2. Motion
The main statement or proposal being debated (for example: “It should be compulsory for children to walk to school to help reduce air pollution”).
3. Proposition (For)
The team or speaker arguing for (in favour of) the motion, proving why the statement is true or beneficial.
4. Opposition (Against)
The team or speaker arguing against the motion, challenging the other team’s evidence and presenting counter-arguments.
5. Balanced Report
Writing or speaking that explores both for and against viewpoints fairly, giving equal weight to opposing sides before reaching a conclusion.
6. Biased View
A one-sided opinion that unfairly favours one viewpoint and ignores or dismisses evidence from the opposing side.
7. Sequencing Connectives
Linking words and phrases—such as firstly, in addition, moreover, therefore, and finally—used to signpost clear points in a speech.
8. Rebuttal (Disprove)
A reasoned response that directly challenges and disproves the opposing team’s argument using facts and logic.
Video Lesson: How to Structure & Deliver a Class Debate
Watch this short lesson on planning arguments for and against a motion, using formal connectives, and speaking persuasively.
Core Lesson: Have a Class Debate
Introduction
Dear learners,
welcome to the Year 6 Debating Chamber at Oakwood Primary School in Oxford! Just like Members of Parliament debating big national decisions in the House of Commons at Westminster, a debate is where each person gets to present their side of an argument, either individually or as a team. Earlier in Unit 5 (Poles apart), we explored how the Arctic and Antarctic sit at opposite ends of the Earth—and today we will discover how people’s opinions on climate change and the environment can also be poles apart!
Brainstorming Scenario: Investigating Contrasting Headlines
Imagine picking up four newspapers at a London train station and seeing these dramatic headlines side by side:
1. What is the main idea presented in these headlines?
2. How does it differ from other views on this topic?
3. Are you surprised to realise that there are two sides to this issue?
• 1. Main Idea in These Headlines: All four headlines claim that climate change and the melting of the Arctic are natural, inevitable events—not caused by human activity.
• 2. How It Differs from Other Views: Most climate scientists and environmental reports argue the opposite—that burning fossil fuels, factory emissions, and transport are major human causes of global warming. Notice how these headlines present only one biased viewpoint rather than a balanced report.
• 3. Two Sides to an Issue: Seeing both sides helps us understand why people debate! When an issue has strong arguments for and against, a formal class debate lets both teams test evidence fairly in front of an audience.
1. It’s Time to Take Sides! (Motions & Opinion Openers)
In a debate, opposing teams compete with one another. The aim is for each team to convince the audience of their argument and disprove the other team’s argument. Look at these three Year 6 debate motions and the persuasive sentence starters speakers use:
“I think it should be compulsory for children to walk to school to help reduce air pollution.”
“Everyone should visit Antarctica to understand climate change.”
“Arctic animals like polar bears should be kept in zoos to protect the species.”
2. Writing Your Speech in Full: Three-Part Structure & Connectives
Before speaking aloud, write out your speech in full and practise saying it clearly. Organise your speech into three clear sections and use formal sequencing connectives (firstly, in addition, moreover, therefore, finally) so the audience can follow every point easily:
1. Introduction
State the motion clearly and announce whether your team is speaking for or against it.
2. Make Three Convincing Points
Support each point with a fact or example, linked by firstly, in addition, and moreover.
3. Conclusion
Use therefore and finally to summarise to convince the audience to vote for your side.
3. Step-by-Step Guide: How a Class Debate Runs (Steps 1–7)
Visual Guide: The Class Debate Chamber & Speech Blueprint
Examples: Model Debate Speeches (For & Against)
Motion: “It should be compulsory for children to walk to school to help reduce air pollution.” Read how two Year 6 speakers from Bristol structure their opposing speeches using connectives:
Model Speech FOR the Motion (Oliver)
Introduction: “Good morning, everyone. I’m convinced that it should be compulsory for children to walk to school to help reduce air pollution.”
Three Points: “Firstly, fewer cars at the school gates will drastically cut exhaust fumes in our town. In addition, daily walking improves children’s fitness and concentration in lessons. Moreover, quieter roads make streets much safer for everyone.”
Conclusion: “Therefore, walking protects both our health and our planet. Finally, I urge you to vote for this motion today!”
Model Speech AGAINST the Motion (Amira)
Introduction: “Honourable audience, I’m against making walking to school compulsory for every child.”
Three Points: “Firstly, many pupils in rural villages live over five miles away with no safe pavements. In addition, heavy rain and icy British winter mornings can make long walks dangerous. Moreover, families can reduce pollution by sharing electric buses or cycling instead.”
Conclusion: “Therefore, a strict rule would be unfair to rural families. Finally, please vote against this motion!”
Educational Game: Whack-a-Fact — Debate Chamber Myth Buster!
Statements pop up in the Westminster Junior Debate Chamber! Tap ONLY the TRUE debate facts (+10 pts) and avoid tapping biased myths or false rules (-5 pts). Reach 60 points to win!
Interactive Activity 1: Debate Rules & Media Bias (5 Questions)
Question 1 of 5Answer one question at a time to test your understanding of debates, climate headlines, balanced reports, and biased views!
Interactive Activity 2: Sort the Debate Arguments (For vs. Against)
0 / 5 Sorted
Motion: “Arctic animals like polar bears should be kept in zoos to protect the species.”
How to play (Mobile & Desktop): Drag each argument card into the FOR (Agree) or AGAINST (Disagree) box—or tap a card to select it, then tap the matching box!
5 Debate Argument Cards (Tap or Drag)
FOR the Motion (Keep in Zoos to Protect)
AGAINST the Motion (Keep in the Wild Arctic)
Interactive Activity 3: Speech Structure & Connectives Challenge (5 Tasks)
Task 1 of 5Complete each task to practise speech sequencing connectives (firstly, in addition, moreover, therefore, finally), speech sections, and debate stages!
Lesson Summary
A debate is a structured discussion where opposing teams compete to convince the audience of their argument and disprove the other side. Unlike a biased article that only shows one viewpoint, a balanced report explores arguments both for and against a motion.
To write a persuasive speech, speakers organise their ideas into three stages: Introduction (state the motion), Three Convincing Points, and Conclusion (summarise to convince the audience), linked with sequencing connectives such as firstly, in addition, moreover, therefore, and finally.
During a class debate, teams present their speeches aloud, answer questions from the audience, and finish with a democratic audience vote to decide which team was more convincing.
End-of-Lesson Assessment (5 Questions)
Question 1 of 5Test your mastery of debating rules, persuasive connectives, balanced reports, and biased viewpoints!
Self-Assessment Competency Checklist (How did I do?)
Tick each box below once you feel confident with the skill: