English: Year 6 9 Sections56 Lessons365 Days
5.7 Read and Assess a Balanced Report
Read and Assess a Balanced Report
Cambridge English Year 6 — Unit 5: Poles Apart
Lesson Competencies
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to read and assess a balanced report, identify topic sentences and connectives, evaluate unbiased evidence on both sides of an issue, and write clear guidelines for balanced reporting.
Key Terms & Word Detective Toolkit
balanced report (noun phrase)
A formal non-fiction text that presents all aspects of an issue fairly (both points for and points against), then leaves the readers to make up their own minds.
unbiased (adjective)
Able to judge fairly because you are not influenced by your own opinions—using formal, neutral language rather than taking sides.
topic sentence (noun phrase)
The opening sentence of a paragraph that clearly introduces its main idea (for example, introducing either the points for or the points against).
connectives (noun)
Linking words and phrases (such as As a result, In addition, therefore, On the other hand, Furthermore, For example, and Hence) that help paragraphs link and flow together.
carbon dioxide emissions (\(\text{CO}_2\))
Greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere by vehicle traffic; high levels of \(\text{CO}_2\) cause the Earth to heat up and trigger extreme weather patterns.
introduction & conclusion
The introduction states the issue clearly, while the conclusion summarises both points and offers a fair, practical recommendation.
Pre-Reading: How a Balanced Report Works
Welcome, Year 6 critical readers! In Unit 5 (Poles apart), we explore big questions where people hold opposite views—such as whether busy British city centres like London, Oxford, or Bath should ban private cars. A balanced report presents all aspects of an issue fairly, then leaves the readers to make up their own minds.
The Four-Part Structure of a Balanced Report
Assessment Criteria: Features of a Balanced Report
It has a clear heading and is divided into paragraphs.
The introduction states the issue.
The conclusion summarises both points giving recommendations.
It is fair to both sides.
Each view is supported with reasons or evidence.
The language is formal and unbiased.
Paragraphs link and flow together using connectives.
Activity 1: Read & Assess the Report — “Is it time to ban cars from city centres?”
Task 1 & 2: Read the report below and notice its key characteristics. Use the spotlight buttons to inspect the structure, topic sentences, and connectives, then answer the assessment questions.
Is it time to ban cars from city centres?
Air pollution is a serious issue and it affects us all directly. Action may be needed to reduce air pollution created by the traffic on our roads.
In the past few decades a significant increase in the number of cars on the road has resulted in more carbon dioxide emissions. Scientists are warning that high levels of \(\text{CO}_2\) in the atmosphere cause the earth to heat up. As a result, we are experiencing more extreme weather patterns. In addition, air pollution in cities causes health problems like asthma. A ban on cars in city centres would therefore reduce air pollution and also improve traffic jams and health issues.
On the other hand such a ban could create other problems. In some cities, public transport is expensive, unreliable or non-existent. In addition, public transport systems would need to be upgraded to cope with greater demand; this requires time and money. Furthermore, personal choice is an issue. For example some people enjoy using public transport but others feel safer in their cars than on a bus or a train. Hence, they may object to being forced to use another mode of transport.
While there is clearly an urgent need to reduce air pollution, we could achieve this in a number of ways. Rather than banning cars in cities, people could be made aware of the issues and encouraged to use less fuel and make use of public transport where possible.
Activity 2: Vocabulary, Connectives & Formal Register
Examine the formal vocabulary and linking connectives that make a balanced report clear, persuasive, and unbiased.
Language & Connectives Toolkit
Notice how the writer avoids emotional slang and instead uses formal British English words such as significant, unreliable, non-existent, upgraded, and object (pronounced ob-JECT, meaning to disagree or protest). Meanwhile, connectives show cause and effect (As a result, therefore, Hence), add extra points (In addition, Furthermore), or introduce an opposing view (On the other hand).
Activity 3: True or False — Balanced Report Assessor & Guidelines
Task 2 & 3: Decide whether each statement about assessing a balanced report, its key terms, and writing guidelines is True or False.
Lesson Summary: Key Takeaways
Purpose of a Balanced Report: A balanced report presents all aspects of an issue fairly, then leaves the readers to make up their own minds.
Clear Four-Part Layout: It uses a question heading, an introduction that states the issue, separate paragraphs for points for and points against, and a conclusion that summarises both views and offers a practical recommendation.
Cohesion & Flow: Each paragraph begins with a clear topic sentence and uses connectives (such as As a result, In addition, therefore, On the other hand, Furthermore, and Hence) so ideas link smoothly.
Formal & Unbiased Tone: Being unbiased means judging fairly without letting personal opinions take over, supporting every argument with reasons or evidence.
Final Assessment: Evaluating a British School Debate Report
Read this short extract from a Year 6 report written for a British school council in York and answer the final assessment questions.
Extract: Should single-use plastic bottles be banned in school?
Plastic waste is a growing concern across the United Kingdom. Many pupils believe our school should ban single-use plastic bottles to protect local rivers and wildlife. In addition, reusable bottles save families money over the school term. On the other hand, some parents argue that busy families occasionally forget reusable bottles, and water fountains may need upgrading to cope with extra queues at break time. Rather than an immediate total ban, the school could install extra bottle-refill stations and reward pupils who bring reusable bottles.
Junior Word Explorer Checklist
Tick each box once you feel confident with the skill: